Tuesday, March 31, 2015

Applying Methods

Bruce Jenner meme
               My specific Bruce Jenner meme can be described with two different methods including Fantasy Theme or Symbolic Convergence Theory. The first method I would be more likely to use would probably be Fantasy Theme. I feel as though this particular theme is great in describing my meme for multiple reasons including that it definitely sparks conversation between those who have viewed the meme. Bruce Jenner was recenetly involved in a car accident where people have made jokes saying, “He drives like a woman” and also “His car has tranny issues” which pokes fun at the fact that Bruce Jenner is going under a sex change from man to woman.

                People all over the internet are leaving comments under this meme photo and the conversation does not stop there, people continue to talk face-to-face about the previous Olympic athlete’s sex change meme joke. People were unable to stop talking about Olympic Gold Medalist Bruce Jenner’s sex change as soon as the news came out. It has continued to spark conversation all over the internet along with people’s questions and comments specifically focusing on this particular meme.

                I understand that “fantasy” in this sense means creative, imaginative interpretation of events which is exactly how you can look at this meme. You can interpret this meme in two different ways. You can take it as if it’s actually talking about a “tranny” as a car part also known as a transmission or as the slang word for a transsexual gender person. There could be a debate about what the actual meaning of this particular meme is along with multiple conversations and their particular meaning for the meme.

Vehicle transmission
                The second method I would choose to use to describe my meme would be Symbolic Convergence Theory.  I would secondly choose this method because it focuses on language and culture which I think is almost key in understanding this meme due to the different interpretations of the word “tranny”. I believe certain cultures may look at this meme differently than others. Also, the language of this meme is important because it can be interpreted into two completely different ways. Depending on the language you use and are familiar with, you will think of the meme in your own individual way. The same goes for culture. Depending on the culture you are used to, whether you live within a very conservative culture you may only understand this meme in one way. If you were brought up in a more liberal culture and setting, you may see the meme in the two different ways it can be interpreted.The language within this meme can capture reach multiple groups of people therefore having different meanings to those different groups.

                You can apply “occam’s razor” to the meme by looking at it in the two different ways it can be interpreted. The simpler choice is probably going to be based upon the individual. If you know and understand the term “tranny” which is a part of a vehicle then this meme may be simpler for you to understand. If you are used to the term “tranny” being used to talk about a transsexual, then you may think it is easier to interpret in that sense.  We all have a different way of looking and understanding things which is why I close this method because it gives individuals a chance to look at things in their own particular way.
                

1 comment:

  1. I appreciate the way you discuss these concepts. Fantasy Theme analysis is the method based upon Symbolic Convergence theory. The idea of Symbolic Convergence, as you alluded to, is about how specific symbols can come to mean different things - and further, how individuals might come to identify with one another based upon a recognition that they all use symbols to mean the same thing; that they "speak the same language." Fantasy Theme analysis, working from this theoretical perspective, allows the critic to analyze the group or groups who respond to a message in a particular way. In this case of this meme/joke, using the word "tranny," like you said, represents a nod to the car part - and perhaps thus a signal to those who might use words like "tranny" to mean car parts - who would certainly also be very likely to make fun of Bruce Jenner. Additionally, including the phrase "It's not my fault" is also a signal to that same group of people - those who might likely perceive TV celebrities as being people who can get away with anything and not be responsible for their actions.

    The Occam's Razor idea is generally applied when searching for the correct interpretation when more than one exists. This play on words is ironic, but is not really vague or difficult to understand. Is this meme image used in different ways? Or is Jenner just a good target for ridicule because of his unusual lifestyle choices as well as his family's very public personage? This particular meme seems to be a good example of a fairly typical sharp criticism drawn from stereotypes and current events - like a lot of comedian's material. Fantasy Theme analysis would give you a chance to describe the sorts of groups who might resonate with this. This accident occurred some time ago, and has been out of the news recently. Is Jenner still a target of this sort?

    I like your thoughtfulness here, and you discuss these concepts pretty well. Remember that Symbolic Convergence is the theory upon which Fantasy Theme criticism is based. Let me know how I can help!

    ReplyDelete